Janitor AI vs Secrets AI: which AI companion app is better?
Janitor AI vs Secrets AI: Secrets AI wins by a wide margin, 8.5 to 6.1, with editable memory, pictures, video and calls; Janitor AI is text only, but its free tier gives unlimited chat with millions of community bots.
Community bots and free unlimited chat
Unlimited chats, standard models, about 9k context
Try Janitor AI freeOur pick
Long stories with editable memory
20 messages a day, no images or calls
Try Secrets AI freeOur verdict
Janitor AI is where many people go for free, unfiltered text roleplay. Chat is unlimited on the free tier with its own JanitorLLM model and about 9k tokens of context, and you can plug in your own API key or proxy. Janitor+ at $12.99 a month on the US App Store adds five times the context, faster replies and monthly swipes on its best models. There are no images, voice or calls.
Secrets AI covers the two gaps in Janitor AI: memory and media. Its Lorebook stores cast, world and relationship details you can edit, and Premium ($9.17 a month yearly) includes 8,000 Moments a month for 18+ pictures, video and live calls. The cost is a free plan of 20 messages a day. Janitor AI has iPhone and Android apps, with adult content off until you switch it on from the website. See the Janitor AI alternatives page for more.
- You want unlimited free text roleplay
- You want to plug in your own AI model or key
- You want millions of community bots to choose from
- You want memory that holds a long story together
- You want pictures, video and live calls
- You want one companion rather than many bots
Janitor AI vs Secrets AI side by side
| Feature | Janitor AI | Secrets AI |
|---|---|---|
| Our score | 6.1/10 | 8.5/10 |
| Cheapest plan | $12.99/mo Janitor+ monthly, US App Store |
$9.17/mo Premium yearly plan, billed $109.99 per year |
| Month to month | $12.99 | $19.99 |
| Free plan | Unlimited chats with millions of bots on standard models, with about 9k tokens of context | 20 messages a day, basic memory, 500-character messages; no Moments, so no images, video or custom characters |
| Pictures | No | Yes |
| Video | No | Yes |
| Voice notes | No | Yes |
| Live voice calls | No | Yes |
| Group chats | No | Yes |
| A character builder | Yes | Yes |
| 18+ chat | Yes | Yes |
| Memory | Conversational | Lorebook + legacy |
| Company | Janitorai Inc., United States (Claymont, Delaware address) | Secret Labs Inc., United States (Dover, Delaware address) |
| Refunds | Generally non-refundable, except where its terms or the law require | No refund for the current billing period; access runs to the end of it |
| Monthly visits | 198M visits a month | 5.9M visits a month |
How they score
First bar Janitor AI, second bar Secrets AI. How the scores work.
Price and free plans
Secrets AI is cheaper: its lowest plan works out at $9.17 a month against $12.99 for Janitor AI. Janitor AI costs $12.99 month to month. Secrets AI costs $19.99 month to month, so paying yearly saves 54%.
Janitor AI free plan: Unlimited chats with millions of bots on standard models, with about 9k tokens of context. Secrets AI free plan: 20 messages a day, basic memory, 500-character messages; no Moments, so no images, video or custom characters.
Features compared
Both apps offer a character builder and 18+ chat. Only Secrets AI offers pictures, video, voice notes, live voice calls and group chats.
Memory: Janitor AI is listed as conversational, Secrets AI as lorebook + legacy.
Who runs them, refunds and billing
Janitor AI is run by Janitorai Inc., United States (Claymont, Delaware address). Secrets AI is run by Secret Labs Inc., United States (Dover, Delaware address). Janitor AI refunds: Generally non-refundable, except where its terms or the law require. Secrets AI refunds: No refund for the current billing period; access runs to the end of it.
Frequently asked questions
Is Janitor AI better than Secrets AI?
Secrets AI scores higher in our ranking, 8.5 against 6.1 out of 10. It comes out ahead on conversation, memory, pictures and video.
Which is cheaper, Janitor AI or Secrets AI?
Secrets AI, from $9.17 a month against $12.99. Both prices are the cheapest plan each app advertises, usually billed yearly.
Do Janitor AI and Secrets AI have voice calls?
Janitor AI: no voice features advertised. Secrets AI: yes, live voice calls.
Which has the better free plan?
Janitor AI: Unlimited chats with millions of bots on standard models, with about 9k tokens of context. Secrets AI: 20 messages a day, basic memory, 500-character messages; no Moments, so no images, video or custom characters.
Can Janitor AI and Secrets AI send pictures and videos?
Janitor AI: pictures no, video no. Secrets AI: pictures yes, video yes.
More comparisons
Keep reading
- Janitor AI reviewUnlimited free roleplay with community bots, but text only.
- Secrets AI reviewThe deepest memory we track, but the free plan is text only.
- Janitor AI alternativesSites like Janitor AI with pictures, voice and lasting memory.
- Secrets AI alternativesCheaper plans, bigger free tiers and phone apps instead of Secrets AI.
- Compare appsEvery AI girlfriend app compared head to head.
- Best AI girlfriend appsThe full ranking of every AI girlfriend app we track.
